Reviews provided by Syndetics
Library Journal Review
This collection of approximately 100 short essays from 30 scholars provides analysis and discussion on virtually every one of Brahms's compositions. The works are grouped in chapters according to genre. Larger works (e.g., symphonies) are given individual essays, and smaller ones (e.g., songs) are grouped chronologically. Each writer was given the freedom to approach the subject independently, and the entries, which range from one to several pages in length, vary in the amount of biographical, historical, and analytical material they contain. Some of the essays are chatty, while others are quite technical. Botstein, president of Bard College and director of the American Symphony Orchestra, provides some unity in an introductory overview of Brahms's life and short introductions to each of the five major chapters, but for the most part this is a reference book for the serious Brahms lover.ÄTimothy J. McGee, Univ. of Toronto (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publishers Weekly Review
Botstein, president of Bard College and director of the American Symphony Orchestra, presents this helpful and user-friendly compendium as the "first and only annotated catalog of Brahms' music in English." Essays by such scholars as Walter Frisch and Michael Musgrave (whose Cambridge Companion to Brahms is forthcoming) are gathered into chapters on Orchestral Music, Chamber Music, Solo Piano Music, Solo Lieder and Vocal and Choral Music. Botstein himself, who writes on many vocal works, has a welcome tendency toward brevity, and never goes on too long about minor works or even major ones. All the essays are anchored in the composer's life, revealing such matters as his relations with Robert and Clara Schumann as well as other still-debated details of his love life. Some of the more outstanding essays in this vein are by Jan Swafford, author of Johannes Brahms: A Biography, who introduces the "Alto Rhapsody" in a way guaranteed to appeal even to those who consider Brahms to be merely "Gloomy Joe," as the EMI record producer Walter Legge used to sarcastically refer to him, adding: "The main problem with Brahms is that he never got syphilis." By contrast, the book's writers' are all Brahms enthusiasts, and their excitement is infectious, in good part because the essays are not permitted to go on to Brahmsian lengths. Botstein has compiled a valuable, welcome addition to the bibliography. (Mar.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Booklist Review
Originally scheduled to appear in 1997, the centenary of Brahms' death, this "annotated catalog," as editor Botstein modestly if accurately calls it, must be reckoned one of the most welcome latecomers ever, at least by admirers of the last of classical music's great "three B's." In it, every piece of Brahms' music accorded an opus number is annotated by one of 30 Brahms authorities. Each annotation covers a composition's genesis, structure, and critical and popular reception. In order not to discourage those who don't read music, no examples in musical notation appear, though to encourage music readers to go to the scores, neither performance practices nor recordings are mentioned. The annotations are sorted into the book's five large parts on orchestral, chamber, solo piano, solo vocal, or other vocal and choral music, respectively. Botstein provides absorbing culturally and biographically oriented introductions to those parts and discusses Brahms' works without opus numbers in a brief sixth part. Musician and nonmusician Brahmsians alike should revel in this trove of lively, keenly intelligent commentary. --Ray Olson